- Focus and Scope
- Section Policies
- Peer Review Process
- Open Access Policy
- Archiving
- Plagiarism Policy
- Publication Ethics
- Reference Manager
- Author Fees
- Subscriber
- Authorship and Contribution
- Conflicts of Interest
- Research Ethics and Consent
- Allegation of Research Misconduct
- Complaints and Appeals
- Data Avaliability
- Use of Generative AI
- Post-publication Discussions and Corrections
- Intellectual Property Policy
- Copyright Notice and License
- Language
- Journal Management
- Manuscript Type
Focus and Scope
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education publish original research papers, conceptual articles, review articles and case studies. The whole spectrum of Indonesian history, historical learning and history education, which includes, but is not limited to education systems, institutions, theories, themes, curriculum, educational values, historical heritage, media and sources of historical learning, and other related topics.
Section Policies
Articles
Peer Review Process
All submitted manuscripts undergo initial screening by the editorial team to assess their relevance to the journal’s scope and compliance with submission guidelines. Manuscripts that pass this preliminary stage are forwarded to at least two independent reviewers, selected based on their expertise, experience, and scholarly contributions in the relevant historical field. In the event of conflicting evaluations, an additional reviewer may be invited to provide a further assessment.
The journal employs a double-blind peer review policy, in which the identities of both authors and reviewers remain anonymous to ensure objectivity and minimize potential bias. Confidentiality is strictly maintained throughout the process; reviewers are required to treat all submitted materials as confidential and must not disclose any part of the manuscript to unauthorized parties.
Reviewers are asked to evaluate manuscripts based on scholarly rigor, originality, relevance to the journal’s scope, clarity of presentation, and adherence to ethical standards. They are also encouraged to provide constructive feedback to assist authors in improving the quality of their work. To ensure an efficient review process, reviewers are given a specified timeframe to complete their evaluations.
Upon receiving the reviews, the editorial team carefully considers all comments and recommendations to determine the next step. Possible decisions include acceptance, minor revisions, major revisions, or rejection. If revisions are required, authors are expected to address all feedback thoroughly and submit the revised manuscript within the designated timeframe.
The final publication decision is made during the Editorial Meeting, taking into account the reviewers' assessments and the overall quality of the manuscript.
Any manuscript receiving a "revisions required" decision that is not resubmitted within two (2) months from the date of the request will be considered withdrawn by the author(s). If no revised manuscript or request for an extension is received within this period, the manuscript will be automatically rejected and will not proceed to subsequent stages of the editorial process.
This policy is enforced to maintain the efficiency of our publication workflow and to ensure a fair and timely review process for all contributors. Authors are encouraged to revise and resubmit their manuscripts within the given timeframe or contact the editorial team should additional time be required.
Open Access Policy
This journal provides immediate open access to its content on the principle that making research freely available to the public supports a greater global exchange of knowledge.
Open access means that all content is freely available without charge to users or institution. Users are allowed to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to full text articles in this journal without asking prior permission from the publisher or author. This is in accordance with Budapest Open Access Initiative.
Archiving
PKP PN Archiving Services
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education utilizes the Public Knowledge Project Preservation Network (PKP PN) Archiving Services to secure its published articles. Through this service, the journal ensures safe and decentralized digital preservation, guaranteeing long-term access for future readers and researchers.More...
Plagiarism Policy
Plagiarism is strictly prohibited in Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN). Plagiarism constitutes the use of another party's words, ideas, images, or data including one's own previously published work without proper attribution to the original source. Any direct quotation from other sources must be enclosed in quotation marks and clearly cited. Furthermore, if a manuscript's research design, framework, or writing style is influenced by existing studies, those studies must also be explicitly cited. All submitted manuscripts to JOIN undergo similarity checks using Turnitin. If plagiarism is detected, the journal will investigate and handle the case in accordance with the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines and policies.
Publication Ethics
JOURNAL PUBLISHER CODE ETHICS
a) Determining the name of the journal, the scope of science, the timeline, and the accreditation.
b) Determining the membership of the editorial board.
c) Defining the relationship between publishers, editors, peer review and other parties in the contract.
d) Appreciating the confidentiality of the contributing researchers, author, editor, and peer review.
e) Applying the norms and regulations regarding intellectual property rights especially on the copyrights.
f) Conducting the policy reviews on the journals and present it to the authors, editorial board, peer review, and readers.
g) Making the behavior code guidelines for editor and peer review.
h) Publishing journals on a regular basis.
i) Ensuring the availability of resources for sustainability journal publishing.
j) Establishing cooperation and marketing network.
k) Preparing for the licensing and other legal aspects.
EDITOR CODE ETHICS
a) Improving the quality of publications.
b) Ensuring the process to maintain the quality of published papers.
c) Leading the freedom in delivering opinion.
d) Maintaining the integrity of the author's academic track record.
e) Conveying corrections, clarifications, withdrawal, and an apology if necessary.
f) Owning the responsibility for styling and formatting the paper, while the contents and any statements in the paper are the responsibility of the authors.
g) Assessing policies and attitudes of the published journal from the author and peer review to increase responsibility and minimize errors.
h) Having an open minded personality in accepting the new opinion or views of others who is different than their personal opinion.
i) Prohibiting in defending our own opinion, the author or third parties which may result in a false decision.
j) Encouraging the author, in order to make improvements to the paper until it worth to publish.
PEER REVIEW CODE ETHIC
a) Receiving the task from the editors to review the papers and submit the review to the editor, as a matter of determining the feasibility of the paper for publication.
b) Reviewing the papers in a timely manner (on time) in accordance with the style guide based on scientific principles (method of data collection, the legality of the author, conclusions, etc.).
c) Reviewing the papers that have been corrected in accordance with the standards.
d) Encouraging the author to make improvements in the papers by providing feedback, suggestions, feedback, and recommendations.
e) Maintaining the author privacy by covering the results of the corrections, suggestions, and recommendations received by the author.
f) Reviewers must not review any papers who involve the reviewers in its work, directly or indirectly.
g) Following the guidelines for peer review in reviewing papers and assessing the evaluation form paper given by the editors.
h) Reviewing papers substantively by not correcting the grammar, punctuation and mistype.
i) Ensuring the principles of truth, novelty, and originality; prioritize the benefit of the paper for the development of science, technology, and innovation; also comprehending the impact on the development of science writing.
j) Prohibiting in defending own opinion, the author or third parties which may result on decision reference becoming non-objective.
k) Upholding the value of the objectivity and free from any influences.
l) Ensuring the confidentiality of findings in the paper until it is published.
m) Having broad understanding on the expertise and able to provide a review of the paper appropriately and correctly.
n) Refusing to do review if the research is not from the field of expertise. Instead, the peer review should be giving recommendation to the researcher if there is any other expert on the subjects.
o) Having an open minded personality in accepting the new opinion or views of others who is different than their personal opinion.
p) Refusing to do the review if the deadline given by the editor cannot be reached. If absent the peer review should notify the editor as early as possible.
q) The results of the review must be presented in an honest, objective, and supported by clear arguments. Some possible recommendations from the review are:
1) Accepted without repair
2) Accepted with minor repairs (after repaired by the author, it is not necessary to go to peer review)
3) Accepted with major repairs (after repaired by the author, return to the peer review for re-review)
4) Rejected and recommended for other publication
5) Rejected and recommended not to publish to any publication because scientifically the paper is flawed for the community.
r) Giving rejection for the last recommendation as the last choice related to the feasibility of the papers or with indication of severe violations of the code of ethics related to the author.
s) Reviewed papers aren’t allowed to be used for personal or third party interests. Moreover, The use of some of the contents of the reviewed papers must have received permission from the author.
AUTHOR/ARTICLE WRITER CODE ETHICS
a) Author collectively responsible for the work and the content of the article which cover methods, analysis, calculation, and its details.
b) Author immediately responds to the comments made by the peer review professionally and timely.
c) Author should inform the editor if they retract their paper.
d) The author describes the limitations in the study.
e) Author respects the publishers if they demand to not to publish the findings in the form of interviews or through any other media before the publication.
f) The author informs the editor of (a) paper that is part of a phased research, multidisciplinary, and different perspectives.
g) The author makes a statement that the papers submitted for publication is original, has not been published anywhere in any language, and not in the process of submission to another publisher.
h) If there is any error in the paper, the author should immediately notify the editor or publisher.
i) The use of materials from other publications which is copyrighted, should be given a written permission and gratitude.
j) The author refers to the work of others as appropriate in citations and quotations which used in the paper.
k) When delivering new discoveries or improving inventions the authors should mention the job previous researcher/writer/founder.
l) The author is not allowed to give a bibliography of the publications if they do not read the publication.
m) If requested, the authors prepared the proof that the research has already met the requirements of the research ethics including the field notes.
n) Author adequately responds if there are any comments or feedback after the paper published.
Reference Manager
We recommend authors to use a reference manager program such as Zotero or Mendeley.
Author Fees
This journal charges the following author fees.
Article Submission: 0.00 (IDR)
Authors are not required to pay an Article Submission Fee as part of the submission process to contribute to review costs.
Article Publication: 500000.00 (IDR)
If your paper is accepted for publication, you will be asked to pay an Article Publication Fee to cover publications costs of Rp 500.000,00 (five hundred thousand rupiahs)/article.
If you do not have funds to pay such fees, you will have an opportunity to waive each fee. We do not want fees to prevent the publication of worthy work. Please contact us directly for waiver and we will assess your request.
Subscriber
To subscribe printed version of Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN), please contact us.
Editorial Office Print Order Section:
Department of History, Faculty of Social Science, Universitas Negeri Malang
Gedung A6, Jl. Semarang No. 5, Malang
Contact:
Historiography JournalPhone: +62-881-7106-550
Email: [email protected]
Authorship and Contribution
Authorship is reserved for individuals who have made substantial and meaningful contributions to a manuscript. These contributions must extend beyond routine or administrative tasks and involve intellectual input across various stages of the research process. To be listed as an author, an individual must fulfill all of the following conditions:
- Made significant contributions to the conceptualization or design of the study, data collection, analysis, or interpretation;
- Actively participated in drafting the manuscript, providing substantial revisions, or critically reviewing it for important intellectual content;
- Approved the final version of the manuscript for submission and publication; and
- Agreed to be accountable for the integrity of the entire work, including resolving any questions related to its accuracy or ethical conduct.
The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all listed co-authors meet these criteria and that no inappropriate authors are included. All co-authors must have reviewed and approved the final version of the manuscript prior to submission. Requests to add, delete, or rearrange author names are strongly discouraged after submission and will only be considered under exceptional circumstances. In such cases, the corresponding author must provide a detailed justification along with written consent from all affected authors. Once a manuscript is accepted, authorship changes are subject to editorial approval and may be declined if proper documentation is not provided. If a change is required post-publication, it will be handled through a formal correction notice.
Contribution Details
To enhance transparency in scholarly publishing, Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN) encourages authors to clearly outline the specific contributions made by each co-author. This should be done using the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy) framework, which provides standardized terms for various roles such as conceptualization, methodology, software, validation, formal analysis, investigation, data curation, writing original draft, writing review and editing, visualization, supervision, project administration, and funding acquisition. Each author's name should be followed by their specific roles, and this contribution statement will appear alongside the published article. At least one author must act as the guarantor, accepting full responsibility for the integrity of the work from inception to publication.
In addition to the named authors, individuals who contributed to the project in other capacities (including technical support, funding acquisition, general supervision, or scholarly discussions) should be recognized in a dedicated Acknowledgments section. Their full names and institutional affiliations must be listed, and authors are responsible for notifying and obtaining written permission from these individuals prior to inclusion. If a group or institution contributed collectively to the research (e.g., historical archives, research teams, or supporting agencies), their role should be briefly described.
Any assistance from AI-based tools (such as large language models used for drafting or editing text) must be explicitly disclosed in the manuscript. Although these tools may assist in the writing process, human authors remain fully accountable for ensuring the originality, accuracy, and ethical compliance of the content.
Conflicts of Interest
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education is committed to upholding the highest standards of transparency and ethical conduct in scholarly publishing. This policy defines conflicts of interest and outlines the procedures for addressing those involving authors, reviewers, editors, the journal, and the publisher, whether identified prior to or following publication. The journal adheres to the Core Practices established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
1. Definition of Conflict of Interest
A conflict of interest occurs when an individual or entity possesses financial, personal, professional, or academic relationships or interests that could influence, or appear to influence, their objectivity, integrity, or decision-making within the context of research, peer review, editorial work, or the publication process.
2. Identification of Conflicts of Interest
All participants in the publication process, including authors, reviewers, editors, and editorial staff, are required to disclose any potential conflicts of interest relevant to the work they submit, review, edit, or publish. Potential conflicts of interest may include, but are not limited to:
- Financial interests: Funding sources, stock ownership, employment, consulting arrangements, or other financial connections related to the research.
- Personal relationships: Close personal or family relationships with individuals involved in the research or publication process.
- Academic relationships: Academic collaborations or affiliations that may compromise objectivity or create a perception of bias.
- Competing affiliations: Associations with competing organizations that may have conflicting interests in the research or its findings.
- Intellectual property rights: Ownership of patents, copyrights, or other intellectual property rights that could potentially be affected by the research or publication.
3. Handling Conflicts of Interest
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education handles conflicts of interest with care and transparency.
For Authors: Authors must disclose all potential conflicts of interest during the manuscript submission process. If a conflict of interest is identified after publication, authors must promptly notify the editorial board. The editorial board will address the matter transparently and, if necessary, publish a correction or retraction.
For Reviewers: Reviewers must decline invitations to review if they have a conflict of interest that could compromise their objectivity. If a conflict arises during the review process, reviewers must immediately inform the editorial board for appropriate action.
For Editors and Journal Staff: Editors and journal staff involved in the review and publication process must recuse themselves from handling manuscripts in which they have a conflict of interest. Should any uncertainty arise, the editorial board will determine the appropriate course of action.
For the Publisher: The publisher must implement policies to manage potential conflicts of interest within its organization, ensuring that editorial decisions and processes remain free from financial or competing interests.
4. Transparency and Disclosure
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education clearly outlines its conflict of interest policy and informs all stakeholders of disclosure requirements. Disclosures made by authors, reviewers, editors, and other stakeholders will be published alongside the relevant article, review, or editorial to maintain transparency. Furthermore, the journal limits or restricts access to the publication workflow for editors, reviewers, or stakeholders who serve as co-authors on manuscripts submitted to the journal.
Research Ethics and Consent
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN) requires all submitted research to strictly adhere to ethical standards regarding research involving human participants, oral history subjects, and historical sources.
Human Subjects and Oral History Research
When research involves human participants (such as in oral history interviews, ethnographic fieldwork, or community studies), authors must ensure that the study was conducted in accordance with established ethical codes, such as the Declaration of Helsinki or national ethical guidelines for human research. Studies should strive to include representative participant populations (considering gender, age, and background where relevant). Gender and identity terms must be used accurately and respectfully throughout the manuscript.
Authors must explicitly state in the manuscript that informed consent was obtained from all human participants or interviewees. The privacy and dignity of human subjects must be respected at all times.
If a historical study involves animal-related experiments or historical bioarchaeological analysis involving animal remains, authors must comply with relevant institutional or international guidelines (such as the ARRIVE guidelines or the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals). Authors must explicitly indicate in the manuscript that these guidelines were followed, including relevant details such as species, sex, or context where applicable.
Informed Consent and Anonymity
Research participants and historical interviewees have a right to privacy that must not be infringed without informed consent. Identifying details (including full names, personal contact details, or sensitive location data) should not be published in descriptions, photographs, or archival transcripts unless that information is essential for historical analysis and the participant (or their legal guardian) has provided written informed consent for publication.
Obtaining informed consent requires that identifiable participants are made aware of the manuscript to be published and informed whether any materials will be accessible online or in print. Written consent forms must be archived by the author or institution in accordance with local regulations and legal requirements. Non-essential identifying details must be omitted.
If there is any doubt regarding whether anonymity can be maintained, informed consent must be secured. Simple measures, such as blurring face areas in historical photographs, may not fully guarantee anonymity. If identifying features are modified to protect identity, authors must ensure (and editors must verify) that such alterations do not distort the historical or scientific meaning of the work. When informed consent has been obtained, a statement confirming this must be included in the published article.
Allegation of Research Misconduct
Research misconduct involves fabrication, falsification, citation manipulation, or plagiarism in conducting, reviewing, or reporting research and writing articles. When authors are found guilty of ethical misconduct or other serious irregularities in published articles, the Editor must uphold the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record.
In cases of alleged misconduct, the Editor and Editorial Board will follow COPE best practices to resolve complaints and address the issue fairly. This process includes an investigation led by the Editor. Manuscripts found to contain ethical misconduct will be rejected. If a published paper is found to contain ethical misconduct, a retraction notice will be issued and linked to the original article.
The initial step is to validate the allegation and assess whether it meets the definition of research misconduct. This preliminary assessment also includes determining whether the complainant has a conflict of interest.
If a potential violation or significant research irregularity is identified, the allegation will be presented to the corresponding author, who is required to provide a detailed response on behalf of all co-authors. After evaluating the response, further review and expert involvement (such as a statistical reviewer) may be required. If misconduct appears unlikely, clarification, additional analysis, or a published correction (such as a letter to the editor along with a correction notice) may suffice.
Institutions are expected to conduct thorough investigations into allegations of scientific misconduct. Authors, journals, and institutions share the responsibility to ensure the accuracy of the scholarly record. By properly addressing misconduct concerns and taking necessary actions (such as corrections, retractions with replacement, or full retractions), Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education upholds the validity and integrity of the scientific record.
Complaints and Appeals
1. General Concerns or Complaints
If you have any concerns or complaints regarding publication in Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN), please send an email to [email protected]. Please note that we do not oversee or comment on editorial decisions for any of our journals.
We aim to respond to your email within five business days. Our Research Integrity and Inclusion Officer will then conduct an investigation in accordance with COPE guidelines to ensure that proper procedures were followed. This process includes reviewing the submission history and correspondence among the authors, Editors, and reviewers.
You will be informed of the outcome of the investigation in writing. While we aim to resolve issues as quickly as possible (usually within six weeks), some investigations may take longer due to the complexity of the matter, data availability, involvement of multiple authors or papers, or the participation of external parties such as the authors' institutions.
To ensure a fair process, we kindly request that you refrain from public comment until the investigation is concluded.
If you wish to escalate your complaint further, you may contact COPE directly. Further information is available on the COPE website.
2. Complaints About Our Publications
All concerns regarding the content we publish are investigated confidentially and in accordance with COPE guidelines, regardless of the status or identity of the complainant. An internal review is often conducted to decide whether a full investigation is required. Any investigation will be conducted in collaboration with the authors and Journal Editors.
We strive to maintain the anonymity of the complainant as much as possible, although certain complaints may inadvertently reveal their identity. Once the investigation is complete and appropriate action is determined, we will notify the complainant. However, to maintain confidentiality, we cannot provide regular updates during the investigation process.
3. Appealing Editorial Decisions
Editors have broad discretion in deciding whether a manuscript is suitable for their journal. Many manuscripts are rejected without external review, often accompanied by a general rejection statement. Such decisions cannot be formally appealed.
However, if an author believes that the rejection was not in accordance with the journal's policies and procedures, they may submit an appeal by providing a detailed, point-by-point response to the reviewer and editor comments. The Editor will then review the peer review process. If the decision aligns with editorial criteria, the Editor's rejection decision is final.
4. Appealing Post-Publication Corrective Actions
When concerns arise regarding a published article, the Editor will decide (following COPE guidelines, including guidelines on retractions) whether the article needs to be retracted or whether other corrective actions or notices are required.
Authors may appeal this decision if new evidence affecting the initial decision arises before the specified comment deadline. This appeal will be reviewed by the Editor and external scientific advisors. Decisions on appeals regarding retractions and statements of concern are final.
Data Avaliability
Authors are expected to provide a clear and accurate statement regarding the availability of the data supporting the findings of their manuscript. Research data (including historical databases, archived documents, transcribed interviews, or qualitative datasets) should be made accessible whenever possible to enhance transparency, reproducibility, and the advancement of scholarly knowledge. Authors are encouraged to deposit their datasets in trusted public repositories and include a persistent identifier (such as a DOI or permanent link) to ensure long-term accessibility.
If research data cannot be shared, authors must clearly state the reasons, such as legal, ethical, or confidentiality constraints (including participant privacy in oral history research). Any restrictions on data access must be justified and explicitly detailed so readers can understand the limitations.
For articles relying on previously published or publicly available data, appropriate references and access information must be provided. In the case of non-empirical or conceptual articles (such as historiographical reviews or essay opinions) that do not involve original datasets, a Data Availability Statement is generally not required.
Authors must ensure that the data described in the manuscript is consistent with the information provided in the Data Availability Statement. If there is any uncertainty regarding data sharing policies or appropriate repositories, authors are advised to consult the journal editorial office prior to submission.
Use of Generative AI
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN) recognizes the increasing use of Artificial Intelligence (AI), including generative AI and AI-assisted technologies, in scholarly publishing. AI tools can assist authors in improving language clarity, organizing content, and supporting technical processes. However, their use must be managed carefully to uphold academic integrity, originality, transparency, accountability, confidentiality in peer review, as well as privacy, intellectual property, and other rights. This policy applies to authors, reviewers, editors, and editorial staff across the entire process of manuscript preparation, peer review, and editorial handling. AI tools must not be used as a substitute for human critical thinking, scholarly judgment, or professional responsibility.
For the purpose of this policy, AI tools refer to digital systems that utilize artificial intelligence techniques (such as machine learning or natural language processing) to generate, analyze, translate, summarize, or modify textual, numerical, visual, or audio data in a scholarly context. This includes, but is not limited to, generative AI tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, and other large language models; writing and language assistance tools like Grammarly or DeepL; and AI-driven tools for data analysis, coding, visualization, and literature discovery.
Authors may use AI tools provided they remain fully responsible for the content of their manuscript. Basic language assistance (such as grammar checking, spelling correction, and minor readability improvements that do not alter scholarly meaning) does not require disclosure. However, if AI tools are used for more substantial purposes (including rewriting, restructuring, text summarization, translation beyond minor editing, supporting data analysis, or assisting in literature exploration and idea generation), authors must disclose such use. All AI-assisted outputs must be critically reviewed, verified, and validated by the authors to ensure accuracy, reliability, and academic integrity.
The use of AI tools is strictly restricted in several areas. AI must not be used to generate an entire manuscript or substantial portions of original scholarly content as a replacement for the authors' own intellectual contribution. AI must not be used to fabricate or manipulate data, results, or findings, nor to generate citations or references without verifying their existence and accuracy. AI must not be used in ways that constitute plagiarism or infringe upon copyrights or third-party rights. Furthermore, the use of generative AI or AI tools to create or alter images, illustrations, or graphical content in submitted manuscripts is not permitted, unless such use is an integral part of the research methodology and described transparently in a reproducible manner.
Authors hold full responsibility for all content submitted to the journal, including any material generated or modified using AI tools. They must ensure the accuracy, originality, and reliability of the manuscript, verify all references, eliminate bias and factual errors, and ensure proper citation and attribution of all sources. Authors must be able to explain their scholarly contribution and accept full accountability for any errors or ethical issues arising from AI-assisted work. AI tools cannot be listed as an author or co-author, as authorship implies accountability and responsibility that can only be fulfilled by humans.
Authors must ensure that the use of AI tools complies with applicable terms and conditions, particularly regarding privacy, confidentiality, and intellectual property. Confidential, proprietary, or personally identifiable information must not be uploaded into AI tools without adequate safeguards. If AI tools are used beyond basic language assistance, authors must provide a clear disclosure in the manuscript, including the name of the tool, its version (if applicable), the provider, and a description of how it was used. Authors are encouraged to include a statement such as: "During the preparation of this manuscript, the author(s) used [tool name] for [purpose]. All outputs were reviewed and verified by the author(s), who take full responsibility for the content."
Peer review at Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education is grounded in confidentiality and human judgment. Reviewers must not upload manuscripts, review reports, or any related content into AI tools, nor use generative AI to conduct scholarly evaluations or generate review conclusions. Similarly, editors and editorial staff must treat all submitted materials and communications as confidential and must not use AI tools to assist in editorial decision-making. All editorial decisions remain the responsibility of human editors.
The journal may utilize screening tools, including similarity checkers and AI writing detection tools, to support editorial assessments. However, these tools are strictly used as screening aids and do not replace final human editorial evaluation.
Post-publication Discussions and Corrections
Based on COPE Core Practices and WAME guidelines, Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN) emphasizes constructive post-publication discussion and correction to maintain the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record. Key elements of this policy include:
1. Post-Publication Comments
Readers and authors are encouraged to engage in constructive discussions regarding published articles through the journal's online discussion forums or other designated platforms.
2. Corrections
If errors affecting the interpretation or understanding of an article are identified post-publication, the journal will issue a correction to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record. Corrections will be executed transparently, with clear indications of what was changed and why.
3. Retractions
A retraction may be necessary when errors compromise the validity of the research or ethical standards. Retractions will be conducted transparently, following COPE guidelines, accompanied by a clear explanation.
4. Expressions of Concern
If concerns arise regarding the integrity of an article but the available evidence remains inconclusive, an expression of concern may be issued while an investigation is underway.
Intellectual Property Policy
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN) is an open-access journal committed to protecting author rights and supporting the widespread dissemination of scholarly work. The journal respects intellectual property rights and ensures that published articles can be accessed, shared, and reused responsibly.
Authors retain full copyright of their articles published in Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education. The journal does not require authors to transfer copyright. By publishing in the journal, authors grant the journal the right of first publication and permit the journal to identify itself as the original publisher of the article.
All articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0). This license permits others to share, copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon the published work for any legitimate purpose (including commercial use), provided proper credit is given to the author, the original publication is cited, a link to the license is provided, any changes are indicated, and derivative works are distributed under the same license.
Authors are responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts are original and do not infringe upon the intellectual property rights of others. Any use of third-party materials (such as images, tables, illustrations, archival instruments, or substantial text quotes) must be properly cited and, where necessary, used with explicit permission from the copyright holder.
The journal does not tolerate plagiarism, copyright infringement, or redundant publication. All submissions may be screened for similarity using plagiarism detection tools. Manuscripts found to contain plagiarism, unauthorized copyrighted material, or substantial overlap with previously published work may be rejected. If such issues are identified post-publication, the journal may issue a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction.
Authors may share and archive their work (including preprints, accepted manuscripts, and the final published version) in institutional repositories, personal websites, academic networks, or other platforms, provided that the original publication in Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education is properly acknowledged and cited.
The journal accepts manuscripts that have previously been made available as theses, dissertations, conference presentations, working papers, or preprints, provided this is clearly disclosed during submission and does not violate copyright or publication ethics.
The name, logo, website design, and other branding elements of Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education are the property of the journal and its publisher and may not be used in a misleading manner or without permission.
This policy aims to protect authors' rights, promote responsible reuse, and support transparent and ethical open-access publishing.
Copyright Notice and License
1. Author Rights
Authors retain copyright of their work and grant Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN) the right to publish and distribute the article.
Authors are permitted to deposit both the submitted version and the final published version of their article in open-access repositories. When archiving the final published version, authors must include proper acknowledgment of its original publication in this journal.
2. User Rights
All articles published in this journal are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Language
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education (JOIN) accepts and publishes articles in both Indonesian and English.
Journal Management
Historiography: Journal of Indonesian History and Education is published by Universitas Negeri Malang and managed by History Department, Faculty of Social Science, Universitas Negeri Malang. The journal is committed to maintaining high standards of academic integrity, ethical publishing, transparency, and operational sustainability in accordance with international best practices in scholarly publishing.
Manuscript Type
We publish original research papers, conceptual articles, review articles, and case studies focused on history learning and history education as well as related topics. All papers are peer-reviewed by at least two referees. JOIN is published by Universitas Negeri Malang with AGSI (Asosiasi Guru Sejarah Indonesia). This journal managed to be issued four times a year in January, April, July, and October.



